CasinoCityTimes.com

Gurus
News
Newsletter
Author Home Author Archives Author Books Search Articles Subscribe
Newsletter Signup
Stay informed with the
NEW Casino City Times newsletter!
Newsletter Signup
Stay informed with the
NEW Casino City Times newsletter!
Aaron Todd Archives
More Strategy Experts

Gaming Guru

author's picture
 

Multi-entry tournaments a catch-22 for daily fantasy sports

2 September 2015

By Aaron Todd
If you live in the United States, you can't escape the buzz around daily fantasy sports (DFS). Market leaders DraftKings and FanDuel spent all summer ramping up for the NFL season and are spending millions of dollars to acquire new depositing customers.

DraftKings, in fact, ranks fourth in TV advertising spend over the last seven days, with an estimated $16 million. That number puts the company just behind GEICO and just ahead of Ford. A big part of that ad budget has been spent pumping up the site's $10 million Millionaire Maker that will run the first week of the NFL season. The event costs $20 to enter, will feature a $2 million first-place prize, and the site expects to draw a whopping 572,500 entries.

Both DraftKings and FanDuel have been making individual deals with professional sports franchises, though DraftKings has been making the biggest waves, with $300 million in funding from investors and an exclusive marketing deal with sports broadcasting giant ESPN.

DFS operators are now looking to expand beyond the shores of the U.S. In mid-August, DraftKings received a U.K. gambling license, and now Amaya is getting in on the action after acquiring DFS operator Victiv.

The marketing behind these sites is simple: Pick your players, win huge prizes. And no doubt, there have been some average Joes who have come out on top and won some serious cash in massive multiplayer guaranteed prize pool (GPP) tournaments. But the reality for the vast majority of players is that the average sports fan has less of a chance to win in DFS than a home game hero has at a poker table with Phil Ivey.

Never has this been clearer than in a $3 MLB Moonshot event hosted by DraftKings on Aug. 20, 2015. Brandon Anderson, playing under the username banders234, claimed first through fifth and had 13 of the top 14 spots, sucking up $45,667.67, or more than 31% of the prize pool. There were 55,485 entries in the tournament.

"Full disclosure, I used fantasycruncher's import feature to put in my lineups, so yes I used a script (probably obvious)," Anderson wrote on the popular DFS forum RotoGrinders. "I had 480 lineups with 4 stacks. WAS, MIN, NYY and CHC (120 each). Normally what happened tonight would never work out like that."

Except that it has. The massive score wasn't the first for Anderson, who finished second through fifth in the same tournament on June 20, a night that featured a $60,000 guarantee with 22,988 entries.

Anderson, however, is not alone in loading up on lineups in the huge multi-entry GPP events. Twenty-four players had 100 or more entries in the Aug. 20 tournament, totaling 4,270 entries, while 14,719 players entered just once.

Make no mistake, professional DFS bettors are using advanced software to help them decide which players to pick, and in many cases, automatically enter hundreds of lineups in DFS contests. None of the major DFS operators ban the practice, and some in fact make it easier by making salary information (the price you must pay against your "salary cap" to pick a player) available for download in spreadsheet form. Why would they want to ban the practice when Anderson's entries in this tournament alone resulted in more than $185 in rake?

So how did the players with the most entries in this tournament do overall? The ROI of the players who entered 100 or more lineups on Aug. 20 was a whopping 322%. Of course, Anderson's haul makes a comparison of high-volume grinders with the folks who entered just one lineup a bit unfair; removing him from the equation results in a -22.2% ROI for the rest of the group. That's not great, but compare it to the bankroll-busting -57.1% generated by those who entered just one lineup.

In theory, you'd expect a number of $3 players to bink a result and post an ROI much higher than someone who paid $1,440 in entries. But just two players who entered only one lineup (out of 14,719) managed to do that, with one winning $233.33 and the other winning $100.

DFS often draws comparisons to poker, in large part because many of the top players are current or former online poker pros. The difference, however, is that poker pros stay away from low-stakes tables and tournaments because they're not worth their time. But in multi-entry GPP tournaments, while one person might be playing a $3 tournament, there are others playing a $1,000 tournament. They're all playing for the same prizes, but they're not on an equal footing.

It's a catch-22 for operators. The Aug. 20 MLB Moonshot on DraftKings drew 23,028 unique players, thanks in large part to the $145,000 guaranteed prize pool, which included a $12,000 first-place prize. The idea of winning a five-figure prize with a $3 entry is a bit intoxicating. But that prize pool doesn't happen without the players who use software to enter dozens, if not hundreds, of lineups. More than 16.7% (9,301) of the entries in the tournament came from the 149 individuals who submitted 25 or more entries. It just doesn't feel right to have 16.7% of the entries come from 0.65% of the players.

If this particular tournament had limited players to just one entry, and you assume that all the players who entered would have still done so, the prize pool would have been just over $60,000 and first place likely would have been around $5,000. That's still a great return for a $3 investment, but the smaller prize might not be enough incentive for some players. If some of them stayed away, it would make the prize pool even smaller, and the smaller prizes might trigger a downward spiral in terms of traffic and market share.

However, allowing players to submit multiple entries allows those who have written scripts and spent hours and hours analyzing the data to run roughshod over the field. Seeing one player claim 13 of the top 14 spots in a contest is going to clue in some of the recreational players that they're outmatched and it's not worth spending any more money to chase the dream of the big payday.

FanDuel, no doubt, is well aware of this. In its first few years of operation as a DFS site, the company heavily marketed the fact that several of its high-volume players were able to make a living off the site. The marketing message is somewhat different in a recent ad: "More money to more winners than any other site."

Of course, not all DFS contests allow multiple entries. There are plenty of 50/50 tournaments where the top half of the field cashes, loads of heads-up tournaments where you only need to beat one player to win, and smaller field tournaments with 10-20 players that pay out the top 10-20% of the players in the field. But those contests aren't the ones drawing players in, and there's nothing stopping DFS pros from entering single lineups into dozens and dozens of these contests as well.

Right now, operators are in a race for acquisition and aren't worried about retention. But if they want their new players to stick around for the long term, they need to protect inexperienced players from the DFS pros, and the best way to do that is by ending the practice of multi-entry tournaments.

NOTE: The original version of this story stated that DraftKings had received $250 million in funding, and not $300 million.
Multi-entry tournaments a catch-22 for daily fantasy sports is republished from Online.CasinoCity.com.
 

Top 10 lessons learned from a five-day bike and poker trip

27 July 2015
Last week, I took a five-day, four-night bicycle trip around Massachusetts and New Hampshire. On three of those nights, I stayed at friends' houses and played in their home poker games. It might sound like a strange idea to a lot of people, but for about a decade, I've dreamed about taking a cross-country bike trip and playing in home poker games along the way. ... (read more)
 

Top 10 quotes from Nolan Dalla's WSOP reports

29 June 2015
Nolan Dalla is the hardest-working man in poker. The World Series of Poker media director wears a multitude of hats during the annual summer series, from running post-tournament interview sessions, to scheduling dinner meetings with poker media, players and others, to fielding random questions from fans and spectators whom he has never met before. ... (read more)
 

Massachusetts 'slots parlor' filled to capacity on opening day

24 June 2015
PLAINVILLE, Mass. — Several hundred patrons stood in line, waiting to be among the first to enter Plainridge Park Casino half an hour before the official opening of the first gaming establishment in Massachusetts on Wednesday afternoon. When the doors finally opened at 11:55 a.m., five minutes ahead of ... (read more)

Next 10 Articles >

  • Featured Articles

Top 10 Fourth of July resort-casino activities

The Fourth of July is coming up next weekend, and casinos across the United States are looking for ways to draw people to their resorts to celebrate the holiday.Here are 10 great ways to celebrate America's independence, and maybe make a bet or two along the way.10. Fourth of July Picnic Buffet at read more)
 

Top 10 binge-watching prop bets

The third season of Orange is the New Black was released on Netflix last week, to the delight of binge-watching TV fans everywhere.My wife and I really enjoy the show, but we were so busy over the weekend that we only got through the first three episodes of the 13-episode season in four days — hardly a binge worth mentioning. ... (read more)
 

Top 10 ways to improve the WSOP Colossus

I spent last week in Las Vegas covering the World Series of Poker's Colossus event. The $565 poker tournament drew 22,374 entries from 14,284 unique players; both numbers broke the record of 8,773 (players and entries) set by the 2006 WSOP Main Event.There's no doubt the tournament was a huge success. ... (read more)
 

Byrnes graduates from WSOP Circuit to Colossus

LAS VEGAS — Bill Byrnes isn't a professional poker player, but if you took a quick glance at his career poker tournament results, you might assume that he is.A 43-year-old attorney from Wentzville, Missouri, Byrnes owns two World Series of Poker Circuit rings and had $143,610 in career tournament earnings ... (read more)
 

WSOP Colossus down to final table

Aditya Prestyo has a huge chip lead heading into Day 4 of the Colossus. LAS VEGAS — The field of the World Series of Poker'... (read more)
Aaron Todd

Home-game hotshot Aaron Todd has covered the gambling industry since 2006. While he is happy to play Texas Hold'em, he'd rather mix it up and play Omaha Hi/Lo, Razz, Deuce-to-Seven Triple Draw, and (his personal favorite) Badeuci.

Since graduating from St. Lawrence University, Aaron has worked as a journalist covering the gambling industry and as a communications specialist in college athletic departments.

A native of a small town in New York just south of Ottawa, Aaron lives in Needham, Mass., with his wife and three children. Write to Aaron at aarontodd@casinocity.com, and follow him on Twitter @CasinoCity_AT.

Aaron Todd

Home-game hotshot Aaron Todd has covered the gambling industry since 2006. While he is happy to play Texas Hold'em, he'd rather mix it up and play Omaha Hi/Lo, Razz, Deuce-to-Seven Triple Draw, and (his personal favorite) Badeuci.

Since graduating from St. Lawrence University, Aaron has worked as a journalist covering the gambling industry and as a communications specialist in college athletic departments.

A native of a small town in New York just south of Ottawa, Aaron lives in Needham, Mass., with his wife and three children. Write to Aaron at aarontodd@casinocity.com, and follow him on Twitter @CasinoCity_AT.